Mother Daughter Exchange Club Episode 35 Review

Well here we are at Episode 35.  This is probably the most controversial of the MDEC episodes we have reviewed to date.  The controversy is in the second half of the Episode.  I have lots of comments on it, but will reserve my commentaries for then when we get there.  So let’s dive into the first half where things are a little more MDEC standard fare. 

It’s nice to see some new faces here as we kick off, and then old reliable Nicole Moore.  We have Mindi Mink with her daughter Marley Matthews, and Nicole with another new daughter Tara Morgan. This scene starts right up at an MDEC get together, with no preamble.  Nicole is instantly talking about how Tara is into cheerleading. Blah blah blah I tuned out for a second, as I was at my get to know you chit chat limit. But quickly I re-engaged as Marley points out to Tara that her mother Mindi is checking Tara out.  Tara doesn't know why she is there.  So she quickly learns about the MDEC.  Nicole tells us that Tara lasts relationship was with a TS (this is a first for us here) and so she should be good with a real woman.  And we learn that Mindi stole Marley's last girlfriend.  Ha ha, I really want backstory on this one.  Sadly we don’t get it.  Nicole and Marley head off to explore the house leaving Tara behind who is very uncomfortable.

There is no beating around the bush with Nicole.  3 mins into the scene (including prelude) and they are kissing.   4 mins in and Marley's top is off.  Marley has bigger boobs than most daughters.  She has a nice natural size. Nicole seems to really enjoy them. And they appear to have on matching underwear. Once Nicole gets her bra off, I am wondering is this the largest natural breast pairing we have seen to date in MDEC?  Maybe Nicole and Hayden ties them.  And Melissa and Evie beats them out.   But its nice to see a scene with large all natural breasts.  Marley has a really nice shaved pussy and Nicole wastes no time enjoying it.  Marley starts out really quite but she picks up the volume a bit towards the end.  Soon thereafter, Marley goes down on Nicole.  I always enjoy Nicole when she says "Yeah Yeah Yeah" (one of my favorite bands btw) or "Right there Right there". I think Marley really likes Nicoles boobs, she is always grabbing them. Nicole sitting on Marley's face is an incredible scene, especially when she clearly loves it.  She also reaches her hand back to finger Marley. Nicole gets behind Marley and kisses her and squeezes her tits.  What a fucking awesome sight!! Nicole goes down on Marley one more time and Marley is much louder this time.  Eventually Marley pushes Nicole down, tribs for a minute, and then rubs her clit. We get some slow kissing to end. This was simple, not too long, never outrageous or wild, and in my eyes great.  ****1/4

Tara is much happier when the other girls are gone. They are drinking wine and enjoying themselves.  We learn that Tara liked her TS friend because they had a penis and boobs.  So of course Mindi asks if she likes her boobs. They kiss and then make their way to the bedroom. Mindi starts by brushing her hair and feeling her up. Tara is really a classic beauty, with an absolutely gorgeous smile.   We get lots of slow kissing to start.  Tara is trying not to be nervous.  Tara is really hesitant as Mindi kisses and feels her boobs.  Her boobs are absolutely amazing by the way. Well at least they were back then.  She has since had implants put in <if I knew how to do it, this is were I would insert lots of crying emojis>. Tara is doing a really good job being shy .  Suddenly Mindi now wants to dress Tara up in white stockings and panties.  That took a weird turn.   Because that is how you encourage everyone during their first time … make them engage in your fetish.    Tara originally has on orange panties that looked just fine.  So year this is kind of weird.  But Tara does look good when in the outfit and sounds really turned on when Mindi strokes her on top of the panties Mindi really takes her time and Tara is clearly turned on.  Tara grabs headboard while Mindi licks her. Eventually the panties come off and we get a view of her beautiful pussy which is nicely bald. She is quite loud and I like it.  Not quite sure what to think of Mindi. She is exotic looking.  Might be really killer if didn’t have big implants.  But they also aren’t excessive looking so I can’t complain too much.  Tara on top is a fun sight.  Tara begs to lick her pussy then pretends to not know how to do so.  I do like Mindi announcing she is going to cum. Mindi asks her to be her girlfriend when they are done.  Tara is completely down with the idea. I like when scenes end like this. I just wished these stories weren’t cast aside the next scene.  Especially since Tara is in the second half of the Episode as a new character.   This was really long and surprisingly light on real action. Not sure there was much to it besides Tara being so hot and into it.  Feels like Tara has way more to offer.  ***1/2

So now we get into the second half and the controversy with the Episode.  For those unaware, we get a depicted incest scene with Raquel Sieb and her daughter Staci Karr.  This is really the last taboo for this series to cross.  The entire series has been based around mothers swapping daughters with their friends.  This seemed to me like the eventual line they would cross.  We have had plenty of step mother sex to date.  We have had it a key part of storyline and kind of an innocent exploration (Dia Zerva and Hayden Night), we have had be naughty and erotic (Simone Sinay and Abigail Mac), and we have had it be pointless and lazy writing (Nicole Moore and Kylie Ryder).  But this upcoming scene is the first time they have depicted a mother having actual sex with her supposed daughter.  I am not going to say I liked the story, in fact as you read you will find I really disliked it.  But not because of the incest, but because of the shitty writing and directing.  As far as the taboo goes, it’s just a movie, and this whole series is so far out there, I am not going to get worked up about it.  I am far more offended that they have Tara playing contradictory characters in the same Episode.  I am far more offended by the inattention to detail and poor direction choices.  

With that said, others clearly think otherwise.  GFF for example, have edited the first 15 minutes out of the scene on their website so that all references to Staci being Raquel’s daughter are gone.  Their explanation is that the topic is no longer meets their quality thresholds.   They also did this back in Episode 14 when Raquel was fighting with daughter Kimberly Gates about Kimberly fucking Raquel’s girlfriend.  And Raquel interjected herself into the scene which kind of ruined it.  There are other websites where you can’t even buy this Episode.  So it appears this topic is the line that is not to be crossed, at least in 2022.  Back in 2014 I guess it was ok.  

So anyway Tara is now Julia Ann’s daughter. Raquel and Staci need another pair to go on a trip with them and so they looked at the MDEC.  Tara and Staci are friends from school so it seems an ideal trip scenario for them each to shack up with their friends mother.   But Julia Ann doesn’t know Tara put her on MDEC. At the get together, Julia Ann and Raquel’s tits are on display. Julia Ann thinks they are there to see horses for sale . Julia Ann is interested in trip but shocked to hear that Tara put them on the MDEC website. Julia Ann leaves as she doesn’t want to be involved with “swinging lesbians”! Staci wants to hook up with Tara even though her mom is out.  Raquel sends them to bedroom to be alone.

Raquel comes to check on them and find out they haven’t started.  So she encourages them all to kiss. When the kiss between Tara and Stacy isn’t to Raquel’s satisfaction she says come kiss mommy. Apparently Staci has been checking Raquel out in shower.  This leads to Raquel feeling her daughters boobs and a real kiss between them.  Tara is kind of turned on, and she and Staci kiss.  Then back to Staci and Raquel. So there you have it, our first real incest of MDEC. It seems odd that Tara isn’t more involved and this is really between the other two to start.  This scene just doesn’t work for me to this point. I don’t really like Raquel who is the focal point and it seems stupid to have Tara be the third party to it all . It starts to pick up pace when Raquel and Tara start in. Tara shreds her top quickly and mother daughter each suck on a beautiful boob in unison.  Staci’s top comes off and we see her lovely small boobs for first time.  One thing I noticed while this was going on was that  Raquels hair looks so greasy.  Not sure what is up with that, not do I understand why I am looking at her hair.  They really play up the mother daughter kissing aspect of this. They start on Staci with Tara licking her and Raquel kissing her and sucking her boobs. Then Raquel lies back and the lick her at the same time before eventually Staci concentrates on the pussy and Tara on the boobs. Finally it’s Tara’s turn and she gets on her knees while mother and daughter finger and lick her. There is a really cool moment where Tara is kneeling on her knees and Staci fingers her while Raquel plays with her boobs.  They all kind of take turns on one another again but it’s far less organized.  Lots of sloppy three way kissing which was cool At one point Tara is fingering both of them while they grind.   Then she stacks them on top of one another and licks them both for a moment from top to bottom. It ends with them all fingering each other.  Kind of wild.  Incest aside, this had lots of energy and enthusiasm.  It is far better than some of the threesomes in MDEC to date, but doesn’t quite approach the better ones.  A solid effort sexually.  But I had an issue with the the direction and flow of the scene as it relates to the storyline as I will now explain.  **** 

Let me state up front that the opening few minutes of this scene were absolutely delightful to me.  Julia Ann is absolutely great here. Julia Ann shows up at Raquel/Staci's house.  "Oh Tara's mom" says Staci when she sees here.  Ha ha. Julia is complaining about horny she is and thinks Raquel can help. She knew Tara was at their house all week but didn't realize that she was with Raquel.  This is why I love MDEC.  This little stories are so insane and absurd that it makes me smile.  Julia Ann throws a temper tantrum and then Staci tells her she is interested, which throws Julia Ann for a loop.  And it is amazing that in the course of a week, Staci will have slept with her own mother, her friend, and her friends mother.  Now that is a worker. But I also find fault in this story.  As part of the threesome, the chemistry was between Staci and Raquel, and Staci and Tara.  If they were going to make Raquel and Tara a couple, they clearly needed to focus on that more during the scene.  I know I shouldn’t be applying logic to this, but I am a mathematician … so sue me.  

Once alone, Staci leans in for a kiss and Julia Ann slows her down. They cuddle on the bed and Staci does lots of touching. They eventually kiss and Julia Ann is suddenly into it. The kisses are very slow.   And I noticed quite the contrast between  the pairs boob size. Of course neither wearing a bra. Julia Ann probably has the nicest implants of any mother we have seen when she lies down. When she is upright you can tell they are store bought.  But they do look soft and nice, and so much better than some of the really bad boob jobs we have seen in this series.  Staci eventually goes down on her slowly licking and fingering. After they switch Staci may be the wettest I have heard anyway to date.   When Julia Ann fingers her you can hear her pussy sloshing so loudly.   That was nice.  Julia Anne sits on her face and you can hear the wetness there too.  We get some nice tribbing with Staci on top to end.  Seemed to start slow and never really got going.  Not sure there was much chemistry between the two.  They looked great, and I liked the story.  But the sex was not all that special.  And we get no word on if Julia Ann will now be going on the trip with the other three.  ***1/2

Overall – This Episode won’t be for everyone.  That is clear enough.  But we got some new faces, the return of a favorite, and some funny moments.  Sex wise it falls in the middle of the pack of the first 35 episodes we have reviewed.  But this has enough good moments to recommend it, as long as you are ok with the incest storyline.  

Awards:

• MVP – Staci, as she has sex with her friend, her friend’s mother, and her own mother all in the course of a week.    This is all time levels of sluttiness.  Well done!!
• Hottest – Tara, although shout out to Marley as well
• Best Mother – Julia Ann, who was great in being offended, and brave enough to come back and get some, and offended again that her own daughter had fucked both members of the family.
• Best Daughter – Marley, who looked great and quickly dragged Nicole off and wasted no time in getting busy.
• Best Scene – Nicole and Marley

Scene Ratings:

• Nicole Moore and Marley Matthews ****1/4
• Mindi Mink and Tara Morgan ***1/2
• Raquel Sieb, Staci Karr, and Tara Morgan ****
• Julia Ann and Staci Karr ***1/2